Ethan Benares topped the Kapuso side of the first PBB Collab 3.0 nominations with 12 points. The most common complaint from his housemates was that he keeps to himself. On the Day 17 episode (November 9, 2026), he explained why, first to Robbie Jaworski in the garden and then to Kuya in the Confession Room.
He faces the first eviction on November 14 with fellow Kapuso nominees Mikee Quintos and Nicole Fortuna.
Twelve points is a lot, and a lot of the reasons were fair. The plate thing really did spiral. But “tahimik” and “fragile” are labels that stick fast in a house of 16 people, and they don’t tell you why someone’s quiet. Day 17 did. I came out of that episode seeing Ethan differently.
Ethan Benares at a glance
From ABS-CBN News:
- Age: 20
- Moniker: “Ang Sporty Palangga ng Bacolod”
- Studies: BS Psychology at the University of St. La Salle
- Showbiz start: Sparkle’s Campus Cutie Season 2
- Side: Kapuso
In a PBB video quoted by ABS-CBN, Ethan said what drew him to the show was “the psychological experiment of meeting new people.” He loves sports and the outdoors. “Mahilig po ako sa camping, fishing, boating, at jet skiing. Basta dagat G ako!” he said in a Sparkle video.
A psych student who signed up for “the psychological experiment of meeting new people,” and then got nominated for not meeting people enough. Medyo ironic, pero mas tao. Knowing how people work and being comfortable around them are two very different skills.
Why Ethan got 12 points
ABS-CBN’s official tally says housemates pointed to “his tendency to keep to himself and his lack of interaction with others.” ABS-CBN’s profile adds that some called him “fragile.”
In the official nomination-reasons video, which we broke down in our first nominees post, the votes came from different directions. Several went back to the plate issue with Calix. Others were about distance: Mikee called him fragile and said he was one of the last people she got close to. Cianne said he seems to have his own life most of the time. Jeo said that when anxiety hits Ethan, he gets angry at himself and pulls away from the group. Shea said, “Naihirapan pa po siya makisama sa amin.”
The garden talk with Robbie
After the nominations, Robbie sat with an emotional Ethan in the garden.

“I’m here for you, bro,” Robbie told him. “I want you to know, pare, you’re a great guy, bro. Don’t let the fact that you’re nominated get to your heart and your mind.”
Ethan tried to explain what group settings are like for him. As much as he wanted to be more extroverted, to talk to a lot of people and hang out in groups, “I really couldn’t. In a group setting, it’s very hard for me to understand everyone as a person, because I’m trying to process a lot.”
Robbie’s answer was simple: “Sometimes the hardest thing to do is to be real with us, to be honest with us. And maybe that’s what you got to do also, bro. It’s not about putting up a front.” Later he added, “Sometimes the greatest act or the greatest sign of showing strength is to show that you can also be vulnerable and honest for the people around you.”
What Ethan told Kuya
In the Confession Room, Ethan said the part he hadn’t said in the garden.

“I didn’t grow up with a dad,” he said. He described feeling “so abandoned every time I loved someone. And it hurts. It really, really, really hurts.” Because of that, he said, he always tries to “run first” when he knows someone is getting close, out of a fear of abandonment.
Kuya told him that being left once doesn’t mean everyone who comes close to him will leave too. People in the house want to know him better, Kuya said: “Give them a chance, and give yourself a chance as well.”
This is where the 12 points start to look different to me. The housemates weren’t wrong about what they saw. He does pull back. Pero ang dahilan, hindi pagiging suplado. It’s a guy who learned early that people leave, so he leaves first. I’m not going to guess anything about his family beyond what he said. What he said was enough.
Where Ethan stands before November 14
Ethan’s last line to Robbie in the garden was “I wish I could have like a longer time with you guys.” Robbie shot back: “Hey, you still have a chance, bro. Ain’t over till it’s over.”
One Kapuso and one Kapamilya will leave on November 14. The public vote decides it, not the nomination points. The voting guide explains how voting works, and our first eviction hub will have the result once the episode airs. You can also read about Ethan’s lolo in our Day 10 memory session post.
Robbie is right that it’s not over. If Ethan stays, I hope he takes Kuya’s advice and lets a few people in. If he goes, he leaves having said the hardest thing out loud on national TV, at 20. Either way, I’d rather remember Ethan for Day 17 than for the plate.
Watch the episode
The garden and Confession Room scenes are in the official Day 17 full episode from Pinoy Big Brother.
